AI-generated exam image draws student complaints

Australia's NSW Education Standards Authority (NESA) sparked public backlash after including an unlabeled, AI-generated image in an English exam, leading to accusations of hypocrisy and concerns over the validity of testing "human experiences" using machine-generated content. What happened The NSW Education Standards Authority (NESA) included an AI-generated image in an English Higher School Certificate (HSC) exam on the subject of “texts and human experiences”. Depicting a serene river scene, the image was created using voice prompts by German AI professional Florian Schroeder using OpenAI's ChatGPT and DALL-E 2 tools. Asked to “analyse” the image's “deeper meaning” and “analyse the composer’s intent”, students quickly raised concerns about the image's authenticity, noting peculiarities that suggested it was AI-generated. After initial denials, NESA confirmed the image's origin. Why it happened The controversy arose because students were tasked with analysing the image in relation to a written passage about farming, leading to confusion and frustration, with many students complaining that using AI-generated content without proper attribution undermined the integrity of their assessments. NESA responded by saying that students would be evaluated based on their responses to the question rather than the image's origin. However, educators expressed concerns about the lack of transparency regarding the use of AI in this instance and more widely in academic settings. What it means The incident highlights growing tensions surrounding the use of AI in education, particularly regarding academic integrity and transparency. It also raises questions about how educational institutions should handle AI-generated content and whether students should be informed about the origins of these kinds of materials. System 🤖 ChatGPT DALL-E 2 Developer: OpenAI Country: Australia Sector: Education Purpose: Generate image Technology: Chatbot; Generative AI; Machine learning Issue: Transparency Timeline ⏰ July 2023. The image is published on a blog by Florian Schroeder, who describes it as AI-generated. October 15, 2024. Students encounter the image in the English Paper 1 HSC exam. Social media platforms erupt with student complaints identifying the image as AI. October 16, 2024. Media outlets and academics confirm the image's AI origins; NESA issues a statement downplaying the impact on marking.

Date it happened

2024-10-01

Organisation involved

Florian Schroeder

Product, system or model

ChatGPT; DALL-E

This is a record of what was reported, not a finding that anyone broke the law. If it names your organisation and you believe it is wrong, the corrections process is free and open to everyone.