Google AI overestimates global supply of Gouda cheese

Google's AI-powered Gemini chatbot made an absurd claim about the worldwide consumption of Gouda cheese in an advert intended to be aired during the US Super Bowl, prompting ridicule and accusations of further degradation of the internet. What happened The spot was set to play during a local ad slot in Wisconsin, the state with the highest cheese production in the US. Intended to help small businesses use AI, the ad shows a Wisconsin cheesemaker asking Gemini to help it write a product description for a Gouda product, to which it responded by claiming that Gouda accounts for "50-60% of global cheese consumption." There is no reliable data on the exact percentage of global cheese consumption that Gouda represents. Experts suggest that while Gouda is popular, especially in Europe, it is highly unlikely to be the most consumed cheese worldwide. Why it happened Google cloud executive, Jerry Dischler, responded by insisting that Gemini was functioning properly and blaming "multiple sites across the web [that] include the 50-60% stat" as the reason the information surfaced within Gemini. The technology company initially defended the statistic, claiming it was "grounded in the web" and found on multiple sites, but ended up updating the ad. What it means The incident demonstrated Gemini's ability to regurgitate unreliable information and generate misinformation and disinformation. It also highlighted inadequate fact-checking by Google. More broadly, the episode serves as a reminder for society not to take information provided by search engines or AI chatbots at face-value. System 🤖 Gemini Resource s 📃 Google - Wisconsin Cheese Mart: Gemini in Google Docs D eveloper: Google Country: USA Sector: Business/professional services Purpose: Generate advertising copy Technology: Gen erative AI; Machine learning Issue: Accuracy/reliability; Mis/disinformation

Date it happened

2025-01-01

Product, system or model

Gemini

This is a record of what was reported, not a finding that anyone broke the law. If it names your organisation and you believe it is wrong, the corrections process is free and open to everyone.