Where automated decisions went wrong

AI transcription tool Otter.ai causes health data breach at Ontario hospital

A former physician at an Ontario hospital installed the Otter.ai transcription tool and gave it access to his digital calendar. Because his personal email was still on a meeting invite list, the AI agent autonomously joined a virtual hepatology round, transcribed it, and emailed the summary and transcript to 65 recipients. The transcript contained sensitive personal health information of seven patients. The hospital reported the breach to the Ontario IPC, took steps to contain it, and is implementing further safeguards.

Company involved

Unnamed hospital in Ontario

AI system involved

Otter.ai

6 source articles · read the reporting →

Poland’s brand chief resigns after backlash over AI-generated report - TVP World

Poland’s brand chief resigns after backlash over AI-generated report TVP World

1 source article · read the reporting →

Meta used AI to target workers with medical conditions for layoffs, lawsuit claims - ddnews.gov.in

Selected employees for layoff, disproportionately affecting those with disabilities or on medical leave

Company involved

Meta Platforms

AI system involved

Metamate

1 source article · read the reporting →

Cigna uses algorithm to deny medical claims without doctor review

Cigna, one of the largest health insurers, used an algorithm called PXDX to automatically deny medical claims. The system flagged mismatches between diagnoses and procedures, and company doctors signed off on denials in batches without reviewing patient files. One patient, Nick van Terheyden, was denied coverage for a $350 vitamin D test that his doctor had ordered. Former employees said the system saved Cigna billions of dollars but left patients with unexpected bills.

Company involved

Cigna

AI system involved

PXDX

10 source articles · read the reporting →

AI scam uses fake video of president as Poland urges action against conmen - TVP World

AI-generated deepfake video of President Nawrocki was used to advertise a fraudulent investment program to internet users

Company involved

Meta

AI system involved

Facebook

1 source article · read the reporting →

Resume prompt injection tricks AI hiring - moneywise.com

AI screening system determined which job applicants to advance to the next stage of recruitment.

1 source article · read the reporting →

Acclarent's AI-Powered Surgery Tool Allegedly Injures Patients, Lawsuits Claim

Two patients allege that Acclarent's TruDi Navigation System, which uses AI to confirm device positioning during sinus surgery, misled surgeons and caused severe injuries including strokes. The FDA has received over 100 reports of malfunctions and at least ten injuries since AI was added. Lawsuits claim the company rushed the technology to market with only 80% accuracy, making the device less safe than before. Acclarent denies any causal connection, and the cases are ongoing.

Company involved

Acclarent

AI system involved

TruDi Navigation System

2 source articles · read the reporting →

Acclarent's AI-Powered Surgery Tool Allegedly Injures Patients, Lawsuits Claim

The TruDi Navigation System by Acclarent, which uses AI to confirm device positions during sinus surgery, has been linked to at least ten patient injuries including strokes, according to FDA reports and two lawsuits. Plaintiffs Erin Ralph and Donna Fernihough allege that the AI was inaccurate and misled surgeons, causing carotid artery damage and strokes in 2022. Acclarent denies the allegations, stating there is no credible evidence of a causal connection. The lawsuits are ongoing.

Company involved

Acclarent

AI system involved

TruDi Navigation System

2 source articles · read the reporting →

Immunefi Bans 15 Users for Submitting ChatGPT-Generated Bug Reports

Immunefi, a crypto bug bounty platform, permanently banned 15 users for submitting bug reports generated by OpenAI's ChatGPT. The platform stated that the reports, while well-written, were nonsensical and wasted time for all parties. Immunefi said it will continue to monitor for AI-generated submissions and may reconsider the ban if AI tools become capable of producing genuine bug reports.

Company involved

Immunefi

AI system involved

ChatGPT

2 source articles · read the reporting →

Montefiore Allegedly Plans to Replace Nurses with AI for Insurance Reviews

The New York State Nurses Association alleges that Montefiore Health System plans to lay off 12 utilization review nurses and replace them with AI-powered software from Datavant. The union warns that the move could compromise patient care by having AI review insurance denials without clinical judgement. Montefiore denies the claims, stating they are investing in technology for better outcomes. The plan has sparked a town hall and calls from elected officials to halt the layoffs.

Company involved

Montefiore Health System

3 source articles · read the reporting →

Sound Intelligence Aggression Detectors Prove Unreliable in School Tests

ProPublica tested Sound Intelligence's aggression detection software, used in hundreds of U.S. schools and hospitals. The algorithm, which analyzes audio for signs of stress and anger, frequently misidentified innocent sounds like coughing as aggressive and failed to detect actual screams. At a New Jersey hospital, the system ignored an agitated man screaming and pounding a desk, escalating the situation. Sound Intelligence's CEO acknowledged the imperfections but defended the technology as an early warning system.

AI system involved

Sound Intelligence aggression detector

2 source articles · read the reporting →

Royal Free London publishes audit into Streams app data processing

The Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust published an audit into its use of the Streams app, following an investigation by the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) in July 2017. The Streams app alerts clinicians to patients at risk of acute kidney injury. The audit, conducted by Linklaters, concluded that the trust's use of Streams was lawful and complied with data protection laws, although areas for improvement were identified. The ICO later recognised that the trust had completed all required actions.

Company involved

Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust

AI system involved

Streams

10 source articles · read the reporting →

Babylon Health attacks clinician who raised safety concerns about its AI chatbot

Dr David Watkins, a consultant oncologist, publicly raised concerns about Babylon Health's symptom triage chatbot, alleging it missed critical conditions such as heart attacks in women. Babylon Health issued a press release attacking Watkins as a 'troll' and manipulating data to discredit his testing. Watkins denies the claims and has filed complaints with the MHRA, which remain pending.

Company involved

Babylon Health

6 source articles · read the reporting →

UK study finds AI cannot detect COVID-19 from cough sounds

The UK Department of Health and Social Care awarded contracts to Fujitsu to develop a "Cough In A Box" app that would use AI to detect COVID-19 from cough sounds, based on earlier claims of high accuracy. However, a study led by the Alan Turing Institute found that machine learning models could not accurately predict COVID-19 from coughs due to confounding variables. The study concluded that the technology does not work for COVID-19 diagnosis.

Company involved

UK Department of Health and Social Care

AI system involved

Cough In A Box

10 source articles · read the reporting →

Finnish recruitment company Digital Minds used AI to analyze job applicants' messages, prompting data protection investigation

Digital Minds, a Finnish recruitment company founded by psychologists, used IBM Watson AI to analyze job applicants' social media and email messages for personality assessments. The company obtained written consent but the Finnish Data Protection Ombudsman launched an investigation, suspecting violations of data protection laws and the secrecy of correspondence. The service was used on fewer than ten applicants and has been paused pending the investigation.

Company involved

Digital Minds

AI system involved

IBM Watson

9 source articles · read the reporting →

Study finds Italian car insurers charge more based on birthplace

A study by the Universities of Padua, Udine and Carnegie Mellon found that Italian car insurers, including Genertel, Mps, Quixa and Con.Te, use birthplace and citizenship in pricing algorithms, charging some drivers over €1,000 more. The practice was ruled against in a 2018 decree involving Linear, but the study says it continues. The companies contacted denied or explained the findings.

Company involved

Genertel, Mps, Quixa, Con.Te

8 source articles · read the reporting →

DeepScore markets facial and voice analysis app for trustworthiness scoring despite experts' doubts

DeepScore, a Tokyo-based company, is marketing an app that uses facial and voice recognition to score people's trustworthiness for lenders and insurers in Japan, Indonesia, Vietnam and the Philippines. The company says the app can detect deception with 70 per cent accuracy, but researchers and privacy advocates say there is no reliable scientific basis for such judgments and warn of discrimination and privacy harms. The chief executive said the system is only one part of lenders' and insurers' decision-making and that people can choose not to use it. Critics respond that an unequal balance of power makes consent difficult.

Company involved

DeepScore

AI system involved

DeepScore

6 source articles · read the reporting →

Hospitals use Epic AI to predict Covid-19 decline without validation

Dozens of hospitals across the US are using Epic's deterioration index AI system to predict which Covid-19 patients will become critically ill, despite the tool not being validated for the new disease. The rapid deployment during the pandemic bypassed normal testing and validation processes.

AI system involved

Deterioration index

9 source articles · read the reporting →

Elon Musk asks X users to upload medical data to train Grok chatbot

Elon Musk has told X users to upload medical images to the platform so that the AI chatbot Grok can learn to interpret them. He claimed Grok can give medical diagnoses, sometimes better than doctors, but experts have raised concerns about accuracy and privacy. The article reports cases where Grok misread a tuberculosis case and a mammogram. xAI, which owns X, responded to Fortune: 'Legacy Media Lies.'

Company involved

X

AI system involved

Grok

6 source articles · read the reporting →

UnitedHealth used ALERT algorithm to limit mental health coverage, regulators found

ProPublica reports that UnitedHealth Group's Optum subsidiary used the ALERT algorithm to flag mental health patients and therapists as outliers, leading to therapy coverage denials. Regulators in California, Massachusetts and New York alleged this breached the federal Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act, and UnitedHealth agreed to restrict the system in those jurisdictions. The company denies wrongdoing and says its programmes are compliant. Affected patients, including Medicaid enrollees, were left to pay out-of-pocket or go without care.

Company involved

UnitedHealth Group

AI system involved

ALERT

5 source articles · read the reporting →

Perth hospital group bans ChatGPT after doctor used it for a patient discharge summary

South Metropolitan Health Service, which runs five hospitals in Perth, ordered staff to stop using ChatGPT for work involving patient information after an email said some staff had used the AI chatbot to write medical notes. The service later clarified that only one doctor had used the tool to generate a patient discharge summary and that no confidential patient information had been breached. The Australian Medical Association has called for national regulations to ensure a human is involved in AI-assisted health decisions.

Company involved

South Metropolitan Health Service

AI system involved

ChatGPT

6 source articles · read the reporting →

Polish DPO investigates OpenAI over ChatGPT false data and lack of transparency

The Polish data protection authority (UODO) is investigating a complaint against OpenAI concerning ChatGPT. The complainant alleges that ChatGPT generated false information about him, and that OpenAI failed to correct it or disclose what data it holds, violating GDPR principles of lawfulness, fairness and transparency. The complainant also claims OpenAI did not fulfil its information obligations under Article 12 and Article 5(1)(a) GDPR. UODO has stated it will examine the systemic compliance of OpenAI's data processing with European data protection law.

Company involved

OpenAI

AI system involved

ChatGPT

9 source articles · read the reporting →

EviCore denied heart catheterization for patient using algorithm

In fall 2021, Little John Cupp's doctor requested a left heart catheterization exam. EviCore, a company hired by UnitedHealthcare, denied the request twice using an algorithm called 'the dial' that adjusts thresholds for review. The algorithm flagged the request for review, and EviCore's doctors determined it was not medically necessary. Cupp did not receive the procedure and his symptoms continued.

Company involved

EviCore (a Cigna company)

AI system involved

the dial

6 source articles · read the reporting →

Cigna StressWaves Test found unreliable and invalid in independent study

A study published in Scientific Reports evaluated the Cigna StressWaves Test (CSWT), an AI tool that claims to assess psychological stress from speech. The study found that the CSWT had poor test-retest reliability and poor validity compared to the Perceived Stress Scale. The authors warned that widespread availability of the tool could lead to misleading results and negative consequences for users making healthcare decisions. Cigna has not publicly responded to the findings.

Company involved

Cigna

AI system involved

Cigna StressWaves Test

4 source articles · read the reporting →